NUS Library Home
NUS Home

How to
Find
Info

Finding Info


Search
LINC now!

 

Critical Evaluation of Resources

Objectivity and Purpose

What you need to find out:
  • Does the author have a bias?

  • What is the purpose of the source?

  • For what audience is the source intended?

  • Is the source scholarly or popular?

How you can find out:
  • Determine whether the author presents a balanced view. Is the language free of emotion-rousing words and bias?

  • Determine if the intention of the source is to report research, inform, present opinions or sell a product. Is the information covered fact, opinion or propaganda?

  • Determine if the information is valid and well-researched or if it is questinable and unsupported by evidence.

  • If the author is associated with an institution or organisation, determine the basic values or goals of the organisation or institution.

  • Determine if the material is scholarly or popular using this list of criteria:

    ScholarlyPopular
    Signed by the authorMay be unsigned
    The author is an expert in the fieldMay be written by someone outside the field
    The author's position and institution are givenThe author's position and institution are not given
    Sources are always cited in the form of footnotes or references References are usually not provided
    The articles published for expert or academic readers and are usually serious and research-oriented. Tables, graphs and diagrams are often included

    The articles are published to entertain the reader, promote a viewpoint and/or sell products and are not based on scholarly research. The articles are usually slick and attractive in appearance or highly illustrated.

    Specialised language is usedSimple language is used
    The journals are published by an association or scholarly press Popular journals usually contain advertisements

    Content by:
    Last updated 21/11/08

© Copyright 2001-2008 National University of Singapore. All Rights Reserved.
Terms of Use | Privacy | Non-discrimination
12 Kent Ridge Crescent Singapore 119275